Thomas Stone 15 and Hemlatha/Hema 17
|
Stone
|
Hema
|
- Very concentrated on, dedicated to, and passionate about work—finger infected, fixes it so his hand works BETTER in surgery
- Stubborn/set in his ways/gifted at usually being right/Short-tempered—throws instruments—cuts open SMJ’s chest to help jumpstart her heart one last way/time.
- Misunderstood/private/loner/Very great surgeon, not so great person SMJ’s delivery
|
Hema—
- Brave/strong: flying/plane “crashing”
- Free-spirited/independent—not willing to marry just because family or others say so
- Stubborn—no smack talk French pilot, Ghosh
|
Step three: paragraphing:
Stone: Misunderstood/private/loner/Very great surgeon, not so great person SMJ’s delivery
Hema Free-spirited/independent—not willing to marry just because family or others say so
Stone is a very gifted surgeon but also a loner and misunderstood man. Thomas is usually superb with his scalpel, but the day Sister has her babies, all his skills vanish. (get quote). (known for courage speed, etc). Ghosh says of Stone, “When a man is a mystery to himself, he can hardly be called mysterious” (35). Really, Stone does not understand himself, realized when he sees his beloved Mary suffering. Perhaps in his isolated life, up until this point, he has not needed to know himself. Or, there has been no one to show him—until Mary. In some ways maybe feelings are riskier to him than operating. For the first time in his life, he encounters a situation over which he has no control, and it is terrifyingly humbling and confusing. Thus a man is only as strong as his greatest weakness—no man is beyond his own frailty, at times.
Hema makes up her own mind. (surprises herself and reacts, grabbing the pilot’s privates pg 79). Even though she is an accomplished gynecologist, an impressive feat for a woman of that day, hers is still arguably a feminine field, even if previously male dominated. At this moment she exerts a character strength she did not know she had. Perhaps the difficult, potentially life-threatening situation elicits this power hitherto unbeknownst to her. However, she did realize she was in a position to speak up, when others felt subdued or intimidated, and she did. Had Hema not valued her own ability to intervene as an individual, perhaps none of these thoughts would have occurred to her, thus none actions either.
What the reader learns about Stone, is he recoils from adversity, while she steps forward to meet it. In the face of saving the babies, Shiva and Marion, for example, Hema is able to remember the health of both the new mother and the infants, while Thomas is not, only focusing on Sister. His tunnel vision is caused by the emotions overwhelming him. In panic he states, “Better out than in,” thinking of the babies as a disease to be removed from the mother, dead or alive is of no consequence. She takes command over the situation when Stone cannot, and probably is why the infants survive. Ironically, even though everyone has worked alongside Stone for the last eight years, this is the first real opportunity any has gotten to know him, even himself. Perhaps this is why Stone runs away. Hemlatha knows herself better, and makes decisions based on that. Such an example is when she agrees to “marriage for a year” to Ghosh—giving herself (and him) the chance to leave if either or both changes their minds. Thus, in life-defining moments like the birth of a child or a marriage proposal, he blows it, while she makes the most of it.
Apostrophes—the two Os—use only for omission or ownership.
Rose bushes’ thorns
The girls’ bathroom
1800s’ technology
Eighteen hundreds
‘80s’ music (19 was omitted, and it's the music that belongs to the 80s--thus we need both apostrophes)
|
Ghosh
|
Marion
|
|
1. “Screw your courage to the sticking place”(find pg) How he handles the riot
2. “You can’t finish if we don’t start, so we better start if we’re to finish” (175). vasectomy
3. Prison scene
4. Hema
|
1. He and Genet “play” in the pantry
2. how he enjoys and is “saved” by Ghosh from being excluded from
Shiva and Marion’s dance lessons by shadowing Ghosh learning medicine
3. Kills military freak
|
Medicine
Uncovering secrets
Love—SMJP and Stone, Marion and Genet, Hema and Ghosh, Rosina Zemui, SMJP and her sister.
Betrayal—between two brother Genet, Stone betrays/abandons babies, SMJP betrays all with her secret (by telling no one), Rosina
Loyalty: Marion loyal to Genet, Shiva loyal to work, Matron loyal to mission,
Death
Suffering SMJP dies for babies, she’s raped and she loses her sister on her way to serve God.
Mystery—mystery behind pregnancy, where Stone goes,
Political history—Ethiopian civil war
|
|
Body 1 Point one—shared or differing quality
|
Evidence/quotation/paraphrase with page numger
|
|
1a. Character/quality one
Ghosh
|
Ghosh knows how to diffuse a bad situation—presence of mind, a type of courage.
|
- “Screw your courage to the sticking place”(find pg) How he handles the riot
|
|
1b. why is this point/quality significant in the essay or to you? What does it mean?
|
Good role model. He keeps cool, gives solid, constructive advice to protect his children.
|
|
1c. Synthesize: why is what you point out important to understand in relationship to some greater context (specify that context)
|
Here, Ghosh shows his strength, leadership, intelligence, and love for his boys by negotiating a dangerous lynch mob, for whom they might very well be the next victims, when people are riled up, not accountable for their actions, and insane. Not just anyone could have pulled that off; he is also showing his sons how to think under pressure. He fully accepts his role as father and the importance of that paternal courage.
|
|
2a. Text/quality/character number two. Marion
|
Marion reveals a first act of courage, in part accidentally.
|
- Kills military freak (find page #)
|
|
2b. explain why this quality is important to you, to the essay, etc.
|
(He and Shiva work this out together.) Readers learn he has Ghosh’s presence of mind, too. He’s twelve years old and standing up to a gun-brandishing madman.
|
|
2c. Synthesis
|
Instinctively, Marion becomes a protector, with the help of his twin in a violent situation. She shows he, too, when pressed, can submit to violence.
|
|
3c-1 now look at the synthesis of each point above (vertically), and comment on what they share and/or what differs.
|
Both take initiative in intelligent ways to protect against mortal danger. They accurately assess in a moment’s notice when forces could spiral out of their control, and somehow, amazingly lasso them in.
|
|
3c-2. What does the comparison/contrast between the texts show/teach/reveal?
|
No matter the outcome, they will be brave enough to “step up to the plate.” Nevertheless, their skill under duress helps to result in the best possible outcome. “Courage to the sticking place” seems to reflect keeping courage pure and an admired quality to foster in oneself in this father and son.
|